Whether or not you believe the U.S. is actually in a recession, there is no denying that times are tough. Every business owner is somehow feeling the pinch and looking for ways to cut costs. To achieve this, reducing headcount is the first thing many employers consider. If you anticipate a long-term or permanent downturn in business, it may be the right approach. However, it’s not the only option. Alternatives to layoffs include temporary reductions in pay, job sharing, shortened workweeks or even small furloughs. Such approaches spread the impact across the board and can help employers retain their experienced talent for when the tide turns. You may be surprised at who is willing to take a week off without pay or every Friday off for a while, especially if the alternative is that their jobs may be lost altogether. If, however, layoffs are inevitable, there are a few things small business owners should think about – unlike layoffs in a large company that may impact one department; a layoff in a small company affects almost everyone directly.
First, while it goes without saying that employees being laid off should be treated with empathy, the damage they can cause if they feel mistreated cannot be underestimated. They know most, if not all of the names of your customers and vendors. If they are not already under some sort of non-compete or non-disclosure agreement, or if you aren’t offering severance that includes a waiver, then the door is open for a potential effort to steal your customers or disclose your confidential business information to competitors. Customers and competitors naturally come to mind when an employee is in panic mode about finding a new job quickly.
Second, once you lay off employees, what about the ones left behind? Will you address them with a glass half full or empty? It’s about balancing morale with honesty, and I’m all for simplicity. Openly acknowledge that times are tight and the layoffs were needed for the health of the organization. Don’t give false hopes or make promises, but show you’re doing what is necessary to protect the business and, ideally, your employees.
Finally, small businesses don’t have an HR department to conduct layoffs, so it’s up to you. When all is said and done, how will YOU feel affected by having let go of employees you probably hired and mentored? If you’ve made appropriate decisions based on solid business needs, then you should take comfort in the fact that these temporary pains are critical to the potential for long-term gains. That doesn’t mean it feels good to have to let go of some employees, but the goal is to protect the company so that the need to have ANY employees will be there for years to come.
Additional Layoff Tips
1. It is an emotional time but cannot be an emotional decision. Who is laid off must be chosen with extreme caution, grounded 100% in business fact. “Last in, first out” may be the safest way but is not always the most practical approach. Performance-based decisions are also common, but you have to be careful about being subjective. Well-defined, specific, measurable criteria must be used. Regardless of the method used, once you make your decision, how does it look on paper? You wouldn’t intentionally discriminate, but if half of those laid off are over forty, and pretty much no one remaining is, then prepare to pay your attorney a lot of money to try to prove that you did not discriminate based on age. A sloppy or subjective decision of who to lay off often leads to these unintentional consequences.
2. If you’re going to give laid off employees any sort of severance or benefit, consult with your attorney to prepare the appropriate waivers. Sure, you can give the pay or benefit as a kind gesture with no strings attached, but consider using it as an opportunity to protect your business. That really is the point of a severance – giving the employee something of value in exchange for a consideration that protects you, such as “you don’t try to sue me for discrimination”.
3. When you conduct the layoffs, be prepared for the reaction, but don’t react to it. As compassionate humans, our instinct is to do or say whatever we can to soften the blow (think “it’s not you, it’s me”). The more you say and engage in conversation, the more you open the door for wrongful termination claims or making reemployment or other promises you can’t keep or have no intention of keeping. Balance empathy with “just the facts, ma’am”.
4. Resist the urge to write letters of reference for those who ask. Again, although unintentional, what if the employees who get letters are largely of one race, and those who don’t are largely of another race? While you may think it is ridiculous that you could ever be accused of discrimination, it happens every day, and accidental discrimination is still discrimination.
This is meant to be general information on a complex topic. It should not be considered legal advice, nor is it a replacement for seeking professional counsel for your specific situation.
Charlotte Jensen is a Human Resources Consultant for small businesses (2-75 employees). As President of Cole James Associates, Ms. Jensen provides her clients guidance on their employment and workplace issues. She can be reached at (804) 339-5576, cjensen@colejamesassociates.com or www.colejamesassociates.com.